Monthly Archives: December 2012

Office hours

I will be holding office hours at The Center on the first Friday of every month (my litigation schedule permitting), starting on January 4, 2013, from 9 – 10 AM.  Please feel free to stop by to talk about anything.  Visitors can also see the Council on Aging in action, a vibrant organization with lots going on.

Unfunded retiree health benefits recommendations

Statehouse News Service reports on recommendations from the state committee studying the unfunded retiree health benefits (Medfield’s are estimated to be about $35m.) –


STATE HOUSE, BOSTON, DEC. 20, 2012..State and municipal employees would have to wait until they are older and put in more years of service to qualify for retirement health benefits under a proposal being embraced by the Patrick administration to cut future benefit costs by $20 billion over the next 30 years.

Gov. Deval Patrick intends to file a retiree health benefit reform plan as part of his fiscal 2014 budget proposal in January that will include the recommendations of a commission that has spent the past nine months reviewing retiree health care costs, said budget chief Jay Gonzalez. He called the plan a “very significant change.”

“In order to present a fair retiree health benefit for employees we need to change the system and the benefit to make it affordable over time and that’s what this reform aims to do,” said Gonzalez, the governor’s secretary of administration and finance.

A commission studying retiree employee health care costs voted 11-1 on Thursday to recommend an increase in the age and years of service required for a state employee to be eligible for health care coverage in retirement.

Shrewsbury Town Manager Dan Morgado, a representative on the commission of the Massachusetts Municipal Association, was the only vote against the recommendations.

The final report adopted by the Commission to Study Retiree Healthcare and Other Non-Pension Benefits recommends increasing the age of eligibility for the majority of state employees in Group 1 from 55 to 60, in line with changes made in 2011 to the state pension system.

The commission also recommended increasing the required years of service in state or municipal government from 10 years to 20 years for an employee to qualify for retirement health benefits. The state currently pays 80 percent of a retiree’s health insurance premiums. Under the new proposal, an employee with 20 years of service would be reimbursed 50 percent of their premiums costs, increasing to 80 percent for those with 30 years of service or more.

The changes would save the state and municipalities $20 billion over the next 30 years, according to Gonzalez, who said the state’s current health benefits for retirees are “among the most generous in the country right now.”

The commission estimated the total unfunded cost of retiree health benefits at the state and local level if the system remains unchanged at $45 billion to $50 billion over 30 years.

The changes, if approved by the Legislature, would be applied to current employees, with some carve-outs and exemptions for those close to retirement. Gonzalez said he thought the package had “a very good chance of passing.”

“This is a strong recommendation of strong reforms to our retiree health benefit structure that will help put the state and municipalities on a path to fiscal sustainability,” Gonzalez said.

The commission was created as part of the pension reform law signed by Patrick in November 2011, and included representatives from the MMA, the AFL-CIO of Massachusetts, the Retired State, County and Municipal Employees Association, the Patrick administration, the Treasury and the House and Senate.

Sens. Jack Hart (D-Boston) and Michael Knapik (R-Westfield) and Reps. John Scibak (D-South Hadley) and F. Jay Barrows (R-Mansfield) also voted in favor of the recommendations.

“We all realize this is a very real challenge and real problem we needed to get our arms around and be part of the solution, said Shawn Duhamel, a commission member representing the Retired State, County and Municipal Employees Association. “I think the proposal that has been put forth that was largely the product of the AFL-CIO and our association achieves not only $20 billion in savings for the next 30 years but provides long-term protections for our members.”

Duhamel called the final recommendations a “tough sell” to many members of his association who will see that $20 billion in savings come out of their pocket. “Given the situation we face, there isn’t a perfect solution, but we’ve done our best,” Duhamel said.

Employees with 20 years of service who are within five years of retirement age would be exempt from the changes, as would employees within five years of qualifying for Medicare eligibility who are within one year of vesting for health benefits.

Teachers participating in Retirement Plus who are 57 or older and are eligible for their maximum retirement benefit would also not see any change to their benefits, and those on disability retirements would be exempt until January 2014 when national health reform kicks in, offering new subsidies for their insurance.

Gonzalez and Duhamel also said the proposal seeks to protect those current employees close to retirement. Employees aged 50 or older with 15 years of service, or 55 and older with 10 years of experience would be eligible to have 50 percent of their health premiums covered in retirement.

While the state currently covers 80 percent of retiree health premiums, cities and towns are free to negotiate their own premium sharing agreements with employees and retirees. The commission’s report will recommend that municipal contribution levels be frozen for a period of three years after the law is enacted, and would prevent communities from changing those rates in the future for existing retirees.

Morgado could not be reached for comment, but the Massachusetts Municipal Association raised concerns about the restrictions on negotiating premium splits in a statement.

“The MMA opposes a recommendation to permanently freeze the health insurance contribution rate for retirees once they retire. This unaffordable provision would prevent cities and towns from making adjustments to a major budget item in order to adapt to changing fiscal conditions and would offset a significant portion of the potential savings in many communities,” the MMA said.

Andrew Powell, the AFL-CIO representative on the commission, said the current system was “unsustainable.”

“There was a recognition that in order to preserve affordable health care for public employees and retirees we had to work on a solution and strike a balance between preserving benefits and the fiscal needs of the state and local government,” Powell said.


Serving the working press since 1910

2013 Warrant Committee has been constituted

From the Moderator –

Scott F. McDermott
Town Moderator

December 20, 2012

Re: 2013 Warrant Committee
Gregory Sullivan of 73 South Street [term expires 2013]
Michael T. Marcucci of 3 Causeway [term expires 2013]
Martha Festa of 16 Quail Run [term expires 2013]

James O’Shaughnessy of 21 Indian Hill Road [term expires 2014]
Maryalice Whalen of 260 South Street [term expires 2014]
Joanna Hilvert of 14 Pueblo Road [term expires 2014]

Gustave H. Murby of 122 Harding Street [term expires 2015]
Nikolaos Athanasiadis of 30 Quarry Road [term expires 2015]
Thomas C. Marie of 72 Pine Street [term expires 2015]

Changes from FY 2012

David Fischer of 22 Stagecoach road Term Expired 2012
Catherine Steever of 7 Acorn Circle Term Expired 2012
Thomas J. Schlesinger of 7 Country Way Resigned [term expired 2013]
Edward P. Doherty of 17 Belknap Road Resigned [term expired 2013]

Profiles of 2013 Warrant Committee Appointees

Nikolaos Athanasiadis lives at 30 Quarry Road with his wife Reka. Nick and Reka have lived in Medfield since 1995, first living on Tubwreck Drive before building their current home 2 years ago. They have three children ages 21, 14, and 12. Nick has degrees in Physics and Computer Science from Brandies University. Nick is a Software Engineer for Akamai Technologies and is an academic tutor and owner of the Math Connection. Nick was a candidate for Selectman in 2012.

Martha Festa lives at 16 Quail Run with her husband Michael. Martha and Mike moved to Medfield in 1990 and they have three children ages 24, 21 and 19 who were educated in the Medfield Public Schools. Martha holds a BS in Chemical Engineering from UMass Amherst, an MBA from Babson College, and has 18 years work experience in industry as a Process Research Engineer, Financial Analyst, Quality Control Manager, Project Manager and Operations Manager at Bayer Diagnostics in Medfield. Martha has extensive volunteer experience with our schools as CSA Treasurer at Dale Street and Blake, Co-President of the Boosters at MHS, and she has worked with programs such as Medfield Neighbor Brigade, St. Edwards Haley House Ministry, fundraising for the Officer McCarthy Children’s Fund, Medfield Turf Project, Warrior Golf Tournament, and recently becoming involved with the Angel Run. Martha has been a member of three Principal Search Committee’s, acting as Co-Chair in 2011.

Michael Marcucci lives at 3 Causeway Street with his wife Emily. He was born and raised in Hamden, CT, and attended Harvard where he met Emily, who grew up in Wellesley. Michael attended Boston College Law School. Michael is a partner in the Boston office of the law firm JonesDay with expertise in business, tort, and securities litigation. Before moving to Medfield in January 2008, Michael and Emily lived in West Roxbury. They have seven children ranging from a 6th grader at Montrose, a 3rd grader at Wheelock, a first-grader and kindergartner at Memorial School, a pre-schooler at Woodside Montessori, and 2 year old twin boys at home. Michael has coached youth sports and his kids have been involved in Girl Scouts, summer swim team, and a great variety of sporting activities. Michael is a trustee of the Montrose School.

Thomas C. Marie lives at 72 Pine Street with his wife Barbara. Tom and Barbara have four boys ages 17, 15, 12 and 10 – all in the Medfield Public Schools. Tom is a graduate of Stonehill College and he is the President and Owner Doublestone Associates. Tom founded Doublestone 11 years ago as a sales agency for manufactured products. Prior to that, Tom was Director of Sales at Tompkins Industries for 10 years. Tom has provided dedicated service to youth in our community as a sports coach and advisor. He is also active at St. Edwards Parish and with his alma mater, Stonehill College.

Appointments to the Medfield Warrant Committee

Under Section 2.9 of the Medfield Town Charter, the Moderator has the duty and privilege of appointing nine members to the Warrant Committee. The Warrant Committee recommends the annual town budget for vote by the town meeting and fulfills all the duties of a finance committee as stipulated in the Massachusetts general laws. Medfield’s Warrant Committee has a proud and dedicated heritage of service to Medfield through collaborative deliberation, dialogue, study, experience and insight. The following is a list of Warrant Committee members appointed or re-appointed in my first ten (10) terms as Medfield’s Moderator. I thank all of them for their great commitment.

Joanne Bragg
Stephen S. Curran
Edward P. Doherty
David Fischer
Mark Fisher
Richard E. Gordet
Diane Hallisey
Joanna Hilvert
William Johnson
Robert Morrill
Debbie Mozer
Gustave H. Murby
Stephen Pelosi
Randy Rogers
Victoria Schepps
Thomas J. Schlesinger
James O’Shaughnessy
James Shannon
Caroline Standley
Catherine Steever
Gregory Sullivan
Maryalice Whalen
Mary Wilson

Needham Bank supports BCRT

Needham Bank Challenge, December 2012
On Track with the Bay Colony Rail Trail
The Bay Colony Rail Trail (BCRT) is the 7-mile long recreational path that traverses through the towns of Needham, Dover and Medfield.
Dear Friends,

We’re delighted to announce that Needham Bank has offered another generous gift, along with a challenge, to support the Bay Colony Rail Trail Association (BCRTA).

Needham Bank was among the first donors to step up and support the BCRTA in a major way when we first started our adventure.

Because the bank is our local community bank – their folks work here and live here – they can see that a safe and beautiful rail trail would be a wonderful asset for all of us who live in the area.

To help us to push ahead with the trail, Needham Bank has extended a challenge that kicks off on January 2, 2013:

For every BCRT supporter who doesn’t currently have a checking account at Needham Bank and who chooses to open one, the Bank will donate $100 to the BCRTA.  Just mention this offer when you open your account. The numbers get quite impressive when you consider that we now have a couple thousand supporters.

Eric Morse, VP at Needham Bank, explained, “We know that people don’t change banks every day, but for BCRTA supporters who are considering doing so in 2013, we hope you’ll consider Needham Bank.   With branches in Needham, Wellesley, Dedham, Westwood and Medfield it’s a great way to show your support of BCRTA. If you’d rather not come into one of our branches, we’ll come to your office or home. It’s so easy to participate in this program. Please contact one of our Branch Managers to schedule an appointment.”

For more on Needham Bank and its services, visit or call them at 781-444-2100.

Best wishes for a wonderful holiday and a very happy New Year.

Best regards,

The BCRTA Board


BCRT volunteers needed… 

The Bay Colony Rail Trail needs help with several activities.

  • Fundraising
  • Project management
  • Outreach to abutters and others
  • Research & Documentation
  • Marketing Communications
  • North Segment Planning

If you might be interested, you’ll have an opportunity to raise your hand and learn more at the Wednesday evening meeting.

Or if you can’t make it to the meeting, drop us an email at and we’ll get you connected to the right people.

Park Street Books to Main Street

Park Street Books is moving to a new location on Main Street, the former  Coldwell-Banker site.  It will continue to be called Park Street Books, per Jim and Teresa James, because of their established on-line presence.  Great for the town  to have a great retail shop in such a prominent site.

Pension reform proposal

Emailed to me by Mike Sullivan –  Swampscott selectmen seek authority to deal with unfunded retirement benefits for new employees –


I wanted to reach out to all Massachusetts municipal officials about a Home Rule Petition the Town of Swampscott is pursuing relative to pension reform. The goal of this petition is to give freedom to each city and town in the Commonwealth to offer an affordable plan for retirement benefits to new hires. As you know, the State of Massachusetts currently mandates a defined benefit plan. In other words, we have no freedom to choose what is a financially sound plan for our city or town.

A quick visit to the PERAC web site details how towns from Andover ($75 million unfunded liability) to Melrose ($45 million unfunded liability) to Swampscott ($36 million unfunded liability) are facing onerous debt that is now and will continue to be a drain on investment in capital improvements, education and town services.

And it will get much worse if we don’t act soon.

Interestingly, the Government Accounting Standards Board (GASB) passed new rules for pension accounting that go into effect in 2013. Two key components of the changes will force pensions to use a much more realistic method of “discounting” or, what most people refer to as investment returns. The State still uses 8.25% as a discount rate for future investment returns by pensions. In its Annual Report, PERAC likes to refer to an average rate of return over the last 27 years of close to 9%. But the reality is that since 2000, the return is closer to 4%. This has a dramatic effect on unfunded obligations and as a result, how much of your property tax revenue is spent on benefits.

GASB will require all municipalities to use a number closer to 2% to determine a true accounting of each system. When that happens, look out below – taxpayers will be shocked to learn how much they are on the hook for in the future. Additionally, GASB will no longer allow for smoothing, which enables pension accountants to meter out the highs and lows, giving a skewed view of the current liabilities and assets. To read exactly what GASB will be requiring, click here.

I believe the State has not done enough to mitigate the risk of pension fund exposure to taxpayers. That is why I’m pushing a Home Rule petition that gives each municipality the right to choose a plan – for new employees – that it finds affordable. Ideally, the State would offer multiple plans to choose from, whether a defined benefit, shared risk or defined compensation plan. For those towns that want to continue down the same path they are on – no problem. But for those of us who are compiling unwanted liabilities and seeing retirees live longer while fewer current employees are paying into the existing plan – we’d have some relief.

This type of system is working in Connecticut, Florida and other states that allow for Home Rule. If you’d like to read articles on successful negotiations between unions and municipal government for new employee benefits, click here.

I’m asking you to join my efforts and help build a coalition for Home Rule. If you would like to see the language Swampscott currently plans to use as an Article this spring at town meeting, please email me and I’ll send over a copy. We are open to suggestions you may have as well.

Thank you,

Barry Greenfield
Selectmen, Town of Swampscott
Editor & Publisher, EfficientGov

Home values down, property taxes up

Article from the email newsletter I get from Massachusetts Department of Revenue –

Average Single-Family Tax Bill Rose $174 or 3.8 Percent in FY12
Bob Bliss – Director of Strategic Planning and Worcester and Springfield Office Manager

The average single-family tax bill in FY12 increased $174 or 3.8 percent in FY12, an increase in line with recent average increases of less than 4 percent, according to the Municipal Data Bank. The increase in average single-family tax bills is largely a reflection of Proposition 2 1/2, which allows for an overall annual tax levy increase of 2.5 percent plus new growth.

The average value of a single-family home in Massachusetts in FY12 was $358,687, and the average property tax paid was $4,711. For FY11, the average value was $361,629, and the average property tax paid was $4,537. For FY10, the average value was $373,702 and the average property tax paid was $4,390. For FY09, the average value was $391,762 and the average property tax paid was $4,250. For FY08, the average value was $403,705 and the average property tax paid was $4,110. For FY07, the average value was $406,673 and the average property tax paid was $3,962.

The decline in the average property value of single-family homes in Massachusetts since 2007 is due to the decline in home values resulting from the 2008 banking industry crisis and the ensuing Great Recession. Since FY2007, the average value of a single-family home in Massachusetts has declined 12 percent. During that same period, the average single-family home property tax has risen 19 percent.

Despite the decline in the average single-family home property value since FY2007, for the 10 years between FY2002 and FY2012, the average value has increased 52 percent, from $236,229 in FY02 to $358,687 in FY12. In that same period, the average single-family tax bill has increased 56 percent from $3,015 in FY02 to $4,711 in FY12.

The drop in the average value of a single-family home of $2,942 from FY11 to FY12 is the smallest since values began their decline in FY2007, indicating that home values have started to stabilize.

Grist Mill status

Letter from the Kingsbury Pond Committee about the progress volunteers are making at the Grist Mill – great news –

Ann E. Krawec
Kingsbury Pond Committee
402 Main Street
Medfield, MA 02052

December 12, 2012

To the Board of Selectmen,

On behalf of our colleagues on the Grist Mill Committee, Dick Judge, Garrett Graham, Andy Spencer and Ann Krawec, I am writing to thank you for your support of the Clark Kingsbury Grist Mill restoration effort, by reinstating the Kingsbury Pond Committee at your August 7,2012 meeting.  The Committee has held its first two meetings, made some interior and exterior improvements, and completed a fact finding field trip to Slater Mill in nearby Pawtuxet, RI. The purpose of this letter is to keep you apprised of our progress on what we consider to be one of Medfield’s most visible historic landmarks on the Rt. 27 gateway into Medfield.

First and foremost, an effort was undertaken to shore up and rebuild the rotted and unsafe decking in front of the mill. We are very grateful for the contributions of time and materials supplied by the Medfield Highway Department in their efforts of reconstruction to the deck and their installation of new sluiceway boards. These two projects alone have provided stability and security for us to lay the foundation to begin our quest to make the mill operational again.  The Kingsbury Pond Committee has a goal, to recreate the transitional phases of mill operation through the centuries- from the early Clark Mill circa 1718 or earlier, to today’s present structure circa 1819, with the addition of the sawmill in 1889. Our historical research leads us to conclude that these progressions included a waterwheel, and a turbine as Significant historical features, which we plan to combine with an educational museum component for the students and community, while providing an aesthetically pleasing scenic destination for fish ing, picnicking, hiking and bird-watching.

Since early spring of 2012, volunteer citizens, too many to mention by name, have contributed by painting the mill, completing small repairs of railings and stairway safety concerns, cleaning the 15 years of powder-post beetle sawdust and accumulated dirt in the interior, repairing the picnic table, broken windowpanes, and adding to the on- site artifacts. Vegetation management volunteers have worked on the exterior surrounding the building, to trim back and control thorny or poisonous overgrowth, improved the driveway with gravel to control dust, and participated in regular mowing and planting of bulbs and herbs and adorned the facade with seasonal decor of pumpkins, Indian corn and, at present, holiday greens and roping. Several organizations have contributed their time and talent and we would like to say a heartfelt thank you to the Medfield Girl Scouts, Boy Scouts, Cub Scouts, and offer our sincerest appreciation for additional contributions from our local contractors including APC Pest Control, Hurley-Testa Construction, and Needham Garden Center to help preserve the structure and the landscape. Medfield’s Highway Department also did a great job installing the new split rail fence along the pond and behind the mill building as was required by the town’s insurance company.

Additional valuable assistance to note with our great appreciation, has been made by Barbara Leighton, Richard DeSorgher, our Town Historian and Curator of the Medfield Historical Society, and David Temple, President of the Historical Society and Historic District Commission member, as well as the Estate of Mike Cronin, and we would like to thank them for their support, insight, historical narrative and contributions of documents, photos and notes of previous mill restoration efforts.

In closing, we would also like to thank our Town Administrator, Mike Sullivan, and you, the Board of Selectmen, for your continued support of our efforts. We will update you periodically on our progress as we move forward to our goal of a fully operational and historic Clark Kingsbury Grist Mill, the next historic jewel in Medfield.

Ann E. Krawec
Kingsbury Pond Committee

MYO brochure

One of Medfield’s treasures is the Medfield Youth Outreach, which does things both wonderful and and large, for a two person department.  After the Board of Selectmen meeting last night I picked up the new MYO brochure at the Town House.

Medfield Green

Here is the calendar of events for Medfeild Green this year, from its website  –


2012 – 2013 Events and Activities

Upcoming Events and Activities through December 2012…

September 15th– Medfield Day, free raffle basket
October 2nd– Movie Night/discussion 7:00-8:45 at the Medfield Library, Award winning Documentary, “BAG IT” You decide how plastic your life will be!
October 19th– Green Family Night, cosponsored by Medfield Girl Scouts and New ‘N Towne- UCC Church 6pm-8pm, Whole Foods presents delicious meatless meals for the family, Butterfly Tree fashion show, lots of fun and green information, crafts and games for kids
November 13th– Natural Pet Care- Medfield library meeting room, 7:00-8:00. How are chemicals harming your pets in their home and in their food? Alternatives?
November 29th– Shopping night at THE BUTTERFLY TREE in Medfield, 10% off to all who mention Medfield Green 7:00pm-9:00pm. Get your holiday shopping done!
December– No programs too crazy! Enjoy the holidays!
January– Energy Program, thermal imaging, alternative energy discussion, geothermal energy. Details to follow
February – Movie night, Award winning movie “Semper Fi” a prelude to our March program “Environmental Causes of Breast Cancer”. Why does our government not protect us? Must see! Details to follow
March– Author Kristi Marsh,will discuss her book Little Changes, Tales Of A Reluctant Home Economics Pioneer, and sign books. She will talk about the 40 things that you can easily do for a healthier life.
April– Movie night, “The Pink Ribbon” Controversial film about the misuse of the pink ribbon for profit. The real story. Details to follow
May 4th– MEDFIELD GREEN DAY, 9-12n, Legion Hall, Zero waste day, donate just about anything!  Check out the link above for more information.
June- Year-end Annual Meeting and Planning.  Details to follow.