Category Archives: Affordable housing / 40B

Affordable housing doings

affordable-housing

The Town of Medfield is currently actively engaged in trying to meet its affordable housing needs, one benefit of which will be to preclude developers from forcing unfriendly 40B developments onto the town.

To be protected from such unfriendly 40B’s, the town needs 10% of its housing to be affordable units (Subsidized Housing Inventory, or SHI) as defined by the Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD).  We are currently at about 7% and need about 150 additional SHI units to be over 10%.  Where the Town of Medfield is not yet at the 10% threshold, to be protected from unfriendly 40B developments int he interim, the town must have a Housing Production Plan (we recently adopted one first proposed about five years ago, which was subsequently approved by DHCD last month), and actually be constructing 21 units of SHI per year.

The Zoning Board of Appeals is currently hearing an application from the Larkin Brothers to build a 40B on Hospital Road consisting of 48 units of single family home condos, 12 of which were to be affordable units, and the remainder market rate units.  At the town’s request,  the Larkins have agreed to amend the project to add one extra affordable unit, so that it will be 49 total units, with 13 affordable units.

Additionally, Bob Borrelli had been permitting the Jacob Cushman house on North Street, across from my office, that he bought from Montrose School for commercial and retail on the first two floors, with two apartments on the third floor, but approached the town about changing the project to be eight rental units under a Local Initiative Program (LIP), with two affordable units.  The Board of Selectmen voted last week to approve that LIP.  Where the LIP is a rental project, under 40B rules, the entire eight units count as affordable (SHI) units.

Thus, the town currently has 21 SHI units in development, which if they get permitted before any other 40B proposal applies to the ZBA for a comprehensive permit, would allow the ZBA to safely decline to approve any 40B applications for the year following the approval of the 21 SHI units.  At the moment, there is somewhat of a race going on between the Mega-B process and the two other 40B projects noted above – if the latter two are permitted first by the ZBA before the Mega-B can apply to the ZBA, then the town will have a one year safe harbor, and the ZBA can say “no” to the Mega-B.

Additionally, I have been meeting and working with Riverside Community Care and The Price Center to see if we could get some group homes built in town, as group homes for disable individuals has the advantage of providing one SHI for each bed, such that a group home for four people gives the town credit for four SHI units..

With that background in mind, Mike Sullivan circulated an email late last week about the status of the Borrelli LIP and the hearing postponement requested by the Larkins.


Kristine Trierweiler has hired a company to do the marketing on Borrelli’s North St. project. She said it would take about two weeks, once they get started. She has been trying to reach Atty Murphy to go over what else Borelli has to do the complete the application to DHCD for a LIP project and will keep trying.

I spoke to the Larkins last night and they said they would have everything ready for the ZBA continued hearing in January. They also told me that the had asked the ZBA for an additional affordable unit and the ZBA was supportive.

Mark Cerel called and said that he had received a response to the neighbors’ appeal of the Conservation Commission’s decision on the Dale St. land. It was from an Attorney Peter Freeman of the Freeman Law Group.

Will update you as more information is available. Mike S

Hospital Road 40B hearing tonight to be continued

40b

Selectmen were told by Mike Sullivan at our Tuesday meeting that tonight’s hearing of the Zoning Board of Appeals on the Larkins’ proposed 48 unit 40B development on Hospital Road will be continued to some time in January, at the request of the Larkins.  It was expected that the ZBA would meet, just for the purposes of continuing the hearing.

Medfield Inclusion Project

Email from Suzanne Siino, after the first meeting of new initiative –

andrew-siino-bb

Thank you for attending the informational meeting for the Medfield Inclusion Project/40Better at the UCC Church last week.  The idea of housing for individuals with disabilities was met with overwhelming support. I am hopeful that you will be part of a team that will be meeting regularly to brainstorm creative and innovative ways to open doors for those who could benefit from supported housing.   This is also a unique way to address the towns 40B deficit, both short and long term.  This is a project that will positively impact the lives of many local families.  Your attendance will make a difference!

 

Be a part of the solution!    The holidays are a time of giving, we need you~

 

A CALL TO ACTION

Tuesday,  December 20, 2016  7 pm  Medfield Public Library Meeting Room

Tuesday, January 3, 2017  7 pm  Medfield Public Library Meeting Room

 

 

With sincere thanks,

 

Suzanne Siino

BoS minutes from 10/18

Meeting Minutes October 18, 2016 draft PRESENT: Selectmen Peterson, Marcucci; Town Administrator Sullivan; Town Counsel Cerel; Administrative Assistant Clarke; Absent Selectman Fisher Selectman Peterson called the meeting to order at 7:00 PM Selectman Marcucci made a motion to nomina~e Selectman Peterson serve as Chairman ofthe Board; motion passed. Selectman Peterson made a motion to nominate Selectman Marcucci serve as Clerk of the Board; motion passed This meeting is being held at the High School Auditorium for the applicants' presentation of the proposed Medfield Meadows project on Dale Street, a 200 unit rental complex and in anticipation of a large crowd the meeting is being held at the high school auditorium. Chairman Peterson announced this meeting is being recorded. He asked for a moment of appreciation for our Troops serving in the Middle East and around the world NEW BUSINESS The Selectmen are requested to vote to sign Agreement for Facilitation Consulting Services with Consensus Building Institute pertaining to the Medfield State Hospital property and it was so voted MEDFIELD HOUSING PRODUCTION PLAN At a duly called and posted meeting on Monday October 17, 2016 the Board of Selectmen and the Planning Board met jointly to review the housing production plan, which was originally drafted in 2012. Discussion ensued and a motion was made and seconded to approve the plan. The Selectmen are requested to vote to sign the submittal letter addressed to the Department of Housing and Community Development and it was so voted. PRESENTATION OF MEFIELD MEADOWS Attending: developer John Kelly, Architect John Winslow and the developer's consultant Geoff Engler; Senator Timilty, Representatives Garlick and Dooley and approximately 700 residents. The project, 200 rental units to be located on Route 27 and Dale Street; three to five story building on the north side with underground parking and a four story building on the other side of 27 also underground parking. Mr. Engler explained that 25% of the units will be affordable, which will give the Town the 10% required by the state's 40B law. In fact all the units will have the Town well over the 10%. He said that they anticipate Medfield residents who are looking to downsize and stay in Medfield will be attracted to these units. October 18, 2016 Page two About 35 or 40 people came to the microphone to voice their opinions about the project. The common thread from all is that this project does not belong in Medfield where there are no other apartment buildings of this size. A resident remarked that the proposed high rise buildings do not belong in Medfield, its place is in Boston. It will overshadow the neighboring established homes; traffic on Route 27 is very heavy now this project will add more than the roads can handle. The developer estimates it will add about 326 vehicles. It will put a burden on municipal services and will increase the school population. Attendees are very surprised to learn that the south side building will have only one entrance and exit on to Dale Street opposite the cemetery. Most residents said that no one is opposed to 40B housing, in fact this project is right near a 40B neighborhood that was built in the early 90"s. It is the size of the buildings and the location that many are opposed to. Geoff Engler stated that the state wants more affordable housing and traffic and increase in school population will not deny a 40B project. Mr. Kelly remarked that they will work to make this project more acceptable to the Town. The audience was dismayed to learn that this is the first project for the developer in the United States. He has done construction in Europe and Canada. Senator Timilty feels that this proposal is more of an urban project for instance in Somerville. The 40B law was meant to increase housing; now developers use it as a weapon to make money. Representative Garlick said that this project is not viewed favorably by MassHousing and that the developer is aware of this fact. Representative Dooley also stated that he will help in any way to make certain this project does not move forward. Selectman Marcucci advised the audience that anyone wishing to make a donation to help defray the Town's cost for special counsel may do so by sending a check to the Town Treasurer noting it is for 40B gift account. Written comments should be emailed to Michael Sullivan or Administrative Assistant Evelyn Clarke. The meeting adjourned at 10:30 PM20161018_page_2

Group homes to avoid the Mega-B

riverside-community-care

Building affordable housing via group homes so as to avoid the Mega-B

This morning I met with the Riverside Community Care CEO, Scott Bock, and its VP of Real Estate and Facilities Management, Chris Burke, along with Mike Sullivan, Kristine Trierweiler, and Jeff Marsden.  We were exploring the town assisting Riverside to locate a group home in Medfield.  The town is especially interested at the moment as we gets credit for each bed in a group home as an affordable housing unit, and hence group home beds could assist the town in building the twenty-one affordable units per year we need to build to have a safe harbor from unfriendly 40Bs.

Riverside Community Care stated that while they want to create a four bed group home in Medfield, the housing costs here make it hard for them to do.  They can buy the same house in Bellingham for less money, so there is a financial gap that needs to be closed for them to afford to create a group home in town.

Riverside needs a 2500 sq. ft. to 3000 sq. ft. home for its four TBI clients, and Chris Burke figures on $150/sq. ft. for construction costs, so around $450,000 for build out.  However, the economics require that the property, all in, only cost Riverside about $500,000,

If Riverside stretched, we ball parked the financial gap at about $300,000 to $400,000 per group home, that would need to be filled by creative financing means.  A direct town payment is too problematic and difficult to achieve (a town meeting vote is needed), so private monies seem to be the most likely means by which it can be done.

The Larkins’ 40B on Hospital Road is slated to give the town twelve affordable units in 2017, if it gets approved, so we would need nine more affordable units in 2017 to be protected for a year.  I have been focusing on group home beds due to my understanding that they would count as soon as the building permits were pulled, and because group homes have been held by case law to be exempt from local zoning as “education uses,” the agencies can go directly to pull a building permit without needing other permitting from the Zoning Board of Appeals or the Planning Board.

If the town can protect itself by creating the twenty-one affordable units the first year, the town still needs to be diligently exploring a myriad of other alternatives for the out years, but I favor the Tilden Village expansion of 40+ units to give us protection for years two and three.  In later years beyond that we will even have enough time to start to explore the use of town owned land.

This morning I gave Riverside a list of eight properties, four of which are on the market starting at $500,000, and four of which are not on the market, but which might work.

The possible ways to bridge the financial gap that we discussed included:

  • land donation, with tax deductions to the owners
  • money donations
  • private fund raising

RU DISTRICT OWNERS

Owners of single family homes in the downtown RU district, who have enough land, can create a two-family house as of right, just by pulling a building permit, so if there are any such home owners in the RU district who would like to have the extra income from allowing a group home to be added onto their existing home, as their “second house” for their two-family, in their own back yard, they should get in touch with me.

 

DHCD corrects HPP date

When the Department of Housing and Community Development(DHCD) approved the Town’s Housing Production Plan this past month, it incorrectly stated the effective date in it approval.  Today the DHCD corrected that error with a new letter (copy attached below) noting the correct date.

Commonwealth of Massachusetts DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Charles D. Baker, Governor + Karyn E. Polito, Lt. Governor + Chrystal Kornegay, Undersecretary November 28, 2016 Mr. Mark Fisher, Chairman Medfield Board of Selectman Town House/ 459 Main Street 02052 Dear Mr. Fisher: The Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD) approves the Town of Medfield's Housing Production Plan (HPP) pursuant to 760 CMR 56.03(4). The effective date forthe HPP is October 19, 2016, the date that DHCD received a complete plan submission. The HPP has a five year term and will expire on October 18, 2021. Approval of your HPP allows the Town to request DHCD's Certification of Municipal Compliance when: • Housing units affordable to low and moderate income households have been produced during one calendar year, totaling at least 0.5% (21 units) of year round housing units. • All units produced are eligible to be counted on the Subsidized Housing Inventory (SHl). If you have questions about eligibility for the SHl, please visit our website at: www.mass.gov/dhcd. • All units have been produced in accordance with the approved HPP and DHCD Guidelines. I applaud your efforts to plan for the housing needs of Medfield. Please contact Phillip DeMartino, Technical Assistance Coordinator, at (617) 573-1357 or Phillip.DeMartino@state.ma.us, if you need assistance as you implement your HPP. Sincerely, Louis Martin Associate Director cc Senator James E. Timilty Representative Shawn Dooley Representative Denise C. Garlick Sarah Raposa, Town Plarmer, Medfield Osler. L. Peterson, Clerk, Board of Selectman, Medfield Michael J. Sullivan, Town Administrator, Medfield Wright C. Dickenson, Chair, Planning Board, Medfield Stephen M. Nolan, Chair, Affordable Housing Committee, Medfield 100 Cambridge Street, Suite 300 Boston, Massachusetts 02114 www.mass.gov/dhcd 617.573.1100

HHP approved by DHCD

dhcd

Step #1 completed:  The Town of Medfield today received the letter below from the Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD) announcing that our Housing Production Plan had been approved.

Also attached are the two letters from our Representatives, Denise Garlick and Shawn Dooley to DHCD and MassHousing citing issues with respect to the Dale Street 40B proposal.

Commonwealth of Massachusetts DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Charles D. Baker, Governor + Karyn E. Polito, Lt. Governor + Chrystal Kornegay, Undersecretary November 17; 2016 Mr. Mark Fisher, Chairman Medfield Board of Selectman Town House/ 459 Main Street 02052 Dear Mr. Fisher: The Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD) approves the Town of Medfield's Housing Production Plan (HPP) pursuant to 760 CMR 56.03(4). The effective date for the HPP is October 7, 2016, the date that DHCD received a complete plan submission. The HPP has a five year term and will expire on October 6, 2021. Approval of your HPP allows the Town to request DHCD's Certification of Municipal Compliance when: • Housing units affordable to low and moderate income households have been produced during one calendar year, totaling at least 0.5% (21 units) of year round housing wiits. • All units produced are eligible to be counted on the Subsidized Housing Inventory (SIIl). If you have questions about eligibility for the SHI, please visit our website at: www.mass.gov/dhcd. • All units have been produced in accordance with the approved HPP and DHCD Guidelines. I applaud your efforts to plan for the housing needs of Medfield. Please contact Phillip DeMartino, Technical Assistance Coordinator, at (617) 573-1357 or Phillip.DeMartino@state.ma.us, if you need assistance as you implement your BPP. Sincerely, ~~ Associate Director cc Senator Shawn Dooley Representative James E. Timilty Representative Denise C. Garlick Sarah Raposa, Town Planner, Medfield Osler. L. Peterson, Clerk, Board of Selectman, Medfield Michael J. Sullivan, Town Administrator, Medfield Wright C. Dickenson, Chair, Planning Board, Medfield Stephen M. Nolan, Chair, Affordable Housing Committee, Medfield 100 Cambridge Street., Suite 300 Boston, Massachusetts 02114 www.mass.gov/dhcd 617.573.1100 ' ' '· • ~' 1' ~ ~mmo/u,1,1.ealhf oj1 /lt:M:Ja,c,,{u-Jett:J J'd~tcle- q/.!Jt/21"C.Je1itat/t0.1 · ,9late .7'tb1.t120161117-dhcd-ltr-from_page_220161117-dhcd-ltr-from_page_320161117-dhcd-ltr-from_page_420161117-dhcd-ltr-from_page_5

Residents’ submission to MassHousing on Mega-B

Town residents submitted an excellent letter to MassHousing opposing the proposed 40B at the intersection of Rte. 27 and Dale Street.  This is a link to that letter:

20161115-medfield-citizens-letter-to-masshousing-11-15-2016

This is a link to the exhibits attached to that letter:

20161116-medfield-citizens-exhibits-to-letter-11-15-2016

Town letter to MassHousing

This is the final version of the Town of Medfield’s letter submitted to MassHousing this afternoon on the Mega-B:

20161117-town-of-medfield-medfield-meadows-municipal-comment-letter-11-17-16

Submittals to Mass Housing

Rendering

Mass Housing gave the town an extension to November 18 to submit comments on the proposed Mega-B at Dale Street and Rte. 27.  On Tuesday evening the Board of Selectmen generally adopted the draft prepared for the town by Sarah Raposa based on input from many people.  I have uploaded that draft and linked to it below.  At the selectmen meeting Selectman Marcucci made the suggestion, which was adopted, that the materials on the developer’s history and credentials should both cite the specifics of what has been learned, and should also be placed at the outset, where it is a main concern.

20161118-bos-mass-housing-ltr-to-draft

What is truly remarkable is that Lisa Ogrinc orchestrated citizen input to Mass Housing, and has today submitted to Mass Housing a PDF file containing 220 individual letters from residents noting residents’ specific issues.

20161117-opposition-to-medfield-meadows-220-letters